Harmful Cyanobacterial Bloom Mitigation in an Open Canal System in Wuxi City Using BlueGreen Water Technologies Lake Guard® Oxy Solution

September 19, 2023
Success story

Water Square is an open canal system of ~4 ha, located in Xinwu District,Wuxi City (Fig. 1). The canal system is known to be occasionally subjected to toxiccyanobacterial blooms. Since June 2021, the water has become severely pollutedwith cyanobacteria, resulting in bloom eruptions observed throughout the canal.The cyanobacteria’s unpleasant appearance is accompanied by a foul smell thatcan be sensed in the surrounding area. The Wuxi canal is surrounded by severalbuildings, including the Pullman hotel, Xinnwu District’s government building,and the main offices of several large companies. Every day the canals andwalkways are trafficked by local citizens who walk past the canal on their wayto work. If left untreated, local citizens and employees will not only berepulsed by the unsightly look, but also the repugnant odor and aerosol particlescarrying cyanobacterial toxins. 

Fig. 1. Map of the Wuxi canal (Left), and aerial photograph ofthe canal system (Right). Red arrows mark the location where samples were collected.

Treatment

In order to tackle this severe problem and mitigate the toxicbloom in the Wuxi canal system, BlueGreen implemented a treatment schemeusing the Lake Guard® Oxy product. Treatment dosage was inthe range of 10-100 kg/ha (see Table 1). Following the application of the LakeGuard® Oxy product, immediate improvement inthe water appearance was observed (see Figs. 2&3).

Table 1. Summary of treatment applications with the Lake Guard® Oxy in the Wuxi canal during June, 2021.
Fig 2. Pictures of the Wuxi canalbefore (top panels) and hours after(bottom panels) treatment with the Lake Guard® Oxy product.
Fig. 3. Treatment with the floating and time-releasing granules ofthe Lake Guard® Oxy, using a boat for product application in the water body.

Sampling Methodology

Water was sampled in the canal for cyanobacterial presence andtoxicity. Phytoplankton species detected were:Cyanophyta sp., Crytophyta sp., Bacillariophyta sp.,Xanthophycaea sp., Euglenophyta sp., Chlorophyta sp., andPyrrophyta sp. Toxicity was determined asmicrocystins level, the most prevalent cyanobacterialtoxins (MC-RR, MC-LR, MC-LF, and MC-LY types were measured).
In –situ digitalmeasurements were performed for dissolved oxygen (DO%), pH, chlorophyll, and phycocyanin (PC). Laboratory measurements wereperformed for TP (total phosphate), Ammonium (NH4-N), and chemicaloxygen demand, measured using potassium dichromate andpotassium permanganate as the oxidizing agent (CODCr and CODMn, respectively), asindicator of organic pollution.

Results

Following the first treatment with the Lake Guard® Oxy product, the cyanobacterial biomass was effectively reduced. Cyanophyta sp. and Pyrrophyta sp., the most abundant species prior to the treatment exhibited themost substantial decrease (see Fig. 4). The cyanotoxins’ concentrations declinedto below detection levels (see Fig. 5), rapidly achieving the immediate goal ofthe treatment scheme.

Measured dissolved oxygen (DO%) values exhibited great improvementfollowing the treatments, increasing from 79% to ~150%. pH values increasedfrom ~7.5 to ~8.5 (Table 2). Peak values for both DO% and pH were observed onJune 23rd, 2021.

Chlorophyll-a levels plummeted from ~220 to ~30 μg/L.Chlorophyll-b doubled from ~30 to ~60 μg/L. Phycocyanin levels, indicative oftotal cyanobacteria, were at ~60 μg/L prior to treatment, decreaseddramatically to ~10 μg/L after the first treatment, and fluctuated between ~40and ~10 μg/L, finally reaching a value of ~10 μg/L after the last treatment.Total phosphate and ammonia decreased dramatically, exhibiting the greatestdecrease after the treatment on June 23rd. CODMn and CODCrsubstantially decreased from ~50 and ~270 mg/L, to ~5 and ~45 mg/L,respectively.

Table 2. Field measurements of physical and chemical parameters obtainedin the Wuxi canal during June, 2021.
Fig. 4. A summary of phytoplankton families analyzed in the Wuxi canal.Cell count (top panel) and biomass (bottom) are presented for each identified family.The identified families include Cyanophyta sp., Crytophyta sp.,Bacillariophyta sp., Xanthophycaea sp., Euglenophyta sp., Chlorophytasp., and Pyrrophyta sp.
Fig. 5.Toxin levels (μg/L) in Lake Wuxi. Measured toxinsinclude the following microcystin types: microcystin-RR, microcystin-LR, microcystin-LF,and microcystin-LY (MC-RR, MC-LR, MC-LF, and MC-LY, respectively)
Fig. 6. Laboratory measurements for samples collected at the canal: (A)Chlorophyll-a (μg/L), (B) phycocyanin levels (μg/L, as a proxy for totalcyanobacteria), (C) TP (total phosphate), (D) Ammonium (NH4-N), (E)COD Mn, and (F) COD Cr. The vertical dotted lines represent treatments performedwith the Lake Guard® Oxy in the Wuxicanal on June 16, 18, 23, and 25, 2021

Summary

The treatmentusing the Lake Guard® Oxy product showed remarkable results. The productsuccessfully reduced the levels of toxic cyanobacteria species and associatedtoxins immediately after the first treatment. This observation was alsosupported by abiotic parameters, including dissolved oxygen, pH, nutrientlevels, and organic pollution indicators, which exhibited great improvementpost treatment. Strikingly, two key drivers of algal bloom development, phosphatesand ammonium in the photic zone, where samples were obtained, were dramaticallyreduced following the treatment. This is an important step for the remediationand prevention of future cyanobacterial blooms. 
Furthermore,the measured CODMn and CODCr levels, the best indicators of oxidizable organicmatter contamination, point to a fast decline in the organic matter. This maybe partly attributed to the release of hydrogen peroxide (H2O2)by the Lake Guard® Oxy product, but is likely mostly due to bacterialoxidation.

Future recommendations

Regularpreventative treatments with small dosages of the Lake Guard® Oxy productare recommended for avoiding the recurrence of toxic algal blooms. Using theLake Guard® Oxy product regularly will enable ecosystem rehabilitation,while improving the quality and appearance of the water in the canal system, aswell as the odors in the surrounding area.

Mountains above a clear lake

Contact us to make your waterbody safe

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
ISRAEL
Headquarters
16 HaMiktsoot Blvd,
Modi’in-Maccabim-Re’ut,
Israel, 7178096
global@bluegreenwatertech.com
+972 8 645 9666
USA
301 South Hills Village Ste LL200 #452
Pittsburgh, PA 15241
us@bluegreenwatertech.com
+1 866-269-2828
China
Room 1603, Sanlitun SOHO Building A,
North Workers Stadium Road, Chaoyang District, Beijing City, China
china@bluegreenwatertech.com
+86 1851 336 1851
South Africa
3 Villa Montina, Delmare Crescent, Mulbarton Road, Beverley AH, Sandton, Gauteng, South Africa, 2921
sa@bluegreenwatertech.com
+27 82 453 4924